2 Best Boutique Hotels in Lima: Hotel B vs. Villa Barranco

This post may contain affiliate links. If you click one and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I genuinely use or believe will add value to you.

Dreaming of Hotel B in Barranco

I had always dreamed of staying at Hotel B Lima, a stunning Belle Époque mansion in the heart of Barranco. It looks like the kind of place where something glamorous should happen. So when I finally booked it—traveling with my aunt and cousins—I was thrilled to explore one of the best boutique hotels in Lima. From the grand façade to the velvet-draped lobby and refined architectural details, it promised the curated cool you’d expect in the pages of a travel magazine.

And as a Relais & Châteaux property, I expected nothing short of excellence.

Boutique Hotels in Barranco: The Bar Is High

Barranco is not just any neighborhood in Lima. Once a seaside escape for Peru’s upper class, it’s now the artistic and creative heart of the city. Murals bloom on nearly every corner. Historic mansions have been transformed into chic boutique hotels, cutting-edge galleries, and award-winning restaurants.

It’s where colonial elegance meets contemporary creativity, and both Hotel B and Villa Barranco are housed in beautifully restored mansions that reflect this unique character.

But only one truly delivered on the promise.

Hotel B: When Style Falls Short of Substance

The room we stayed in was attractive at first glance, but the charm stopped at the surface. A strong mothball-meets-mildew smell immediately dampened the mood. Things got worse when we discovered that our suite shared an anteroom with others—one of which had been turned into a set for a bridal magazine shoot.

Photographers, assistants, and gear came in and out all day. The staff barely acknowledged the disruption. My aunt kept saying, “I can’t believe this is a Relais & Châteaux. It’s so poorly run.”

We had just returned from the Amazon, and we were ready for a quiet night. But the Hotel B rooftop bar had other plans. Music pumped, and footsteps echoed late into the night. It felt more like a club than a high-end retreat.

Design Over Comfort

The hotel is undeniably stylish—chic cocktails, designer furnishings, and curated art collections abound. But that design-forward experience didn’t translate to guest comfort. The food was fine. The ambiance was loud. The staircases were uneven, the hotel room door wouldn’t lock properly and the hallways were confusing.

The Passport Fiasco

The real disaster came at checkout. The front desk gave our group the wrong passports. My cousins (who aren’t even blood-related) and I may look somewhat alike, but our names are not even remotely similar.

The staff member went one by one, handing us our passports by name. “Here’s yours, Elizabeth”—that’s me. “Here’s yours, Heather,” and so on.

I didn’t realize I had my cousin’s passport until I was already at the airport—just over two hours before my flight.

Panic.

I called the hotel. They promised to send someone on a motorcycle to cut down on travel time. But instead, they waited for their preferred driver, ignoring the many taxis readily available.

I missed my flight, lost my business class seat, and ended up sobbing at the LATAM counter with only a photocopy in hand.

When I returned to the hotel, frustrated and exhausted, there was no apology waiting—only suspicion. They insisted they needed to “review the tapes,” as if this were something we had concocted.

Thankfully, American Express helped me rebook two days later. To their credit, Hotel B offered me a complimentary stay and discounted the original booking—but only after I pushed.

The upside? The upgraded room was fabulous. Like something out of a movie. Beautiful sheets, electric curtains, and a stunning bathroom—finally, a glimpse of the luxury I had imagined.

Villa Barranco: Boutique Luxury Done Right

A few months later, I returned to Lima with a friend, and we decided to stay at Villa Barranco, part of the Ananay Hotels group.

From the moment we arrived, the difference was clear: calm, thoughtful, and beautifully managed.

A Heritage Property With Heart

Villa Barranco is also a restored mansion, but the atmosphere is serene and gracious. One of the co-owners previously managed the Belmond Sanctuary Lodge in Machu Picchu, and his expertise shows in every detail—from the intuitive layout to the warm, attentive staff.

Our rooms were fresh, quiet, and spotless—and yet every corner held a thoughtful piece of art or a curated curio. My friend’s junior suite had a sea view from its balcony, just off a sleeping loft.

And the pièce de résistance? The bathroom.

Truly the most spectacular bathroom I’ve ever seen in a boutique hotel. Bigger than most hotel rooms, with a freestanding tub in the center, double-story atrium skylights, and a fainting couch. Yes, a fainting couch.

It was dreamy.

Breakfast, Breeze, and Boutique Charm

Mornings at Villa Barranco are their own kind of luxury. Breakfast was served on the rooftop during our stay—though that may have changed. The spread was divine: homemade pastries, tropical fruit, eggs, waffles and pancakes made to order, and perfectly brewed coffee.

No techno beats. No film crews. Just peace and sunshine.

Worth Every Sol

My only complaint? Rates have increased since my first stay. But even at the new price point, I’d return in a heartbeat. The service, design, and sense of ease make Villa Barranco one of the best boutique hotels in Lima.

Final Verdict: Which Boutique Hotel in Barranco Is Worth It?

Would I return to Hotel B for a luxury hotel stay? Maybe—for their delightful afternoon tea, another incredible massage, and maybe just to try it again, as I have heard the manager who handled our stay is no longer there. 

But when it comes to where I’d actually want to stay in Barranco—where I want to rest between meals at Isolina and strolls past Barranco’s murals?

Villa Barranco wins. Every time.

Funny Follow-Up

A few months later, my cousin Heather was staying at a chic boutique hotel in the States. She got to chatting with the woman at check-in, who mentioned she had previously worked in Lima.

Heather casually told her the passport switch story at Hotel B—and the woman’s eyes widened.

“OMG, that was you?”

Apparently, our saga became part of Hotel B’s staff training on the importance of verifying passports. So, silver lining? We’re officially hotel lore.